Ressources numériques en sciences humaines et sociales OpenEdition Nos plateformes OpenEdition Books OpenEdition Journals Hypothèses Calenda Bibliothèques OpenEdition Freemium Suivez-nous

Gem: What it takes to represent a current event

Article by Marije Osnabrugge

Every second week of September, a horse fair is held in Valkenburg, a small town just south of Leiden. Coincidentally, this week marks its 1079th edition, according to the website. First documented in 840, this yearly event is characterized by popular entertainment, social gathering, and trade, drawing visitors from nearby villages and cities, but also from far and abroad. We find numerous traces of the fair in the archives, as well as in the visual arts.

Village fairs had long been a popular topic for artists, perhaps most successfully in the oeuvre of Pieter Bruegel the Elder (fig. 1), who masterfully captured the merriment of such events.1 Seventeenth-century landscape painters, including Salomon van Ruysdael and Jan Van Goyen, made drawings and paintings depicting the Valkenburg horse fair (e.g. figs. 2 & 3). Phillips Wouwerman, renowned for his skills in painting horses in battle scenes and landscapes, also captured the scene (fig. 4). Adriaen van de Venne painted the fair in 1618 on an oblong oak panel (fig. 5).2 All these painters approached the subject from their own specialty, shifting the focus of the composition accordingly.

Fig. 2. Salomon van Ruysdael, The Horse Fair at Valkenburg, 1644, oil on canvas (105.3 x 131.4 cm), current location unknown, https://rkd.nl/images/72211.

Fig. 3. Jan van Goyen, The Horse Fair at Valkenburg, 1652, oil on panel (40 x 57 cm), private collection, https://rkd.nl/images/72231.

Fig. 4. Philips Wouwerman (attr.)The Horse Fair at Valkenburg, no date, oil on canvas (66 x 74 cm), location unknown, https://rkd.nl/images/72214.

With the exception of Van de Venne, these artists represented a generic recurrent happening in an easily recognizable location. Van de Venne’s version is the only one which instead depicted a specific historical event: the visit of Frederick Henry and Maurice of Nassau to the fair.3 In this gem, I will briefly consider the formal elements that set Van de Venne’s painting apart from the other representations of the Valkenburg horse fair, on the basis of early modern Dutch art theory.

Occasional depictions of historical events, including special celebrations and disasters, can be found throughout the history of art.4 It nevertheless seems that artists started to capture current events more frequently during the early modern period, arguably in parallel with the increased number of (illustrated) pamphlets and newsletters addressing the present.5 To depict such events, visual artists would naturally conceive of them as history paintings. In early modern Dutch art literature, theorists generally distinguish three types of history painting (i.e. a painting representing a story): mythological, biblical or religious, and worldly (waereldze) histories. In his Groot Schilderboek (1707/1712), Gerard de Lairesse moreover separates mythological and legendary stories from so-called ‘true histories’ (waare geschiedenissen) based on the Bible, the lives of saints, and history.6 No apparent difference is made between historical events from a distant (often ancient) or recent past in these art theoretical texts.

According to early modern Dutch art literature, the main aspects of a convincing history painting can be summarized as follows:

For pictures of the Valkenberg horse fair to be recognized as such, artists needed to observe the first point (1.). Indeed, in all the images evoked above, the weather seems appropriate for September; and they include the recognizable church tower of the town, tents and festivities of the fair, and of course horses. However, to capture the specific historical event of Frederick Henry and Maurice’s visit, Van de Venne made sure that the two men, seated in an ornate carriage, as well as the lord of the town and his wife (Johan de Hertoghe van Orsmael and his wife Josyna de Beye) to whom they pay their respect, would be identifiable to a contemporary audience (2.).10 Remarkably, the two eminent visitors are placed a bit in the background. Some other figures, like the horserider saluting the couple with a levade in the foreground, have not yet been identified by modern scholars, but contemporaries would likely have been able to recognize them by their distinct features.11 The painter has selected the exact moment in which the company greets the couple (4.), according to appropriate etiquette (3.). Lastly, the painter makes the scene plausible by adding all sorts of characters and objects that would be present at a horse fair (5.).

This depiction of a minor historical event thus followed the basic rules of history painting. The occasion appears to have been primarily – arguably even exclusively – of interest to De Hertoghe van Orsmael, for whom the visit of Frederick Henry and Maurice signified an acknowledgment of his status. For this reason, it has been suggested convincingly that he was the commissioner of the painting. We could argue that by following conventions that were traditionally applied to the most well-known and significant histories, the artist provided an air of importance to this episode of personal history.

To Come

Together with my colleagues in WP1, we are studying the visual and textual representation of the present (e.g. by Cordélia Floc’hic and Tilleane Charavel). In WP2, it is the notion of the event that takes center stage. This short overview of art theoretical ideas about history painting and the particular case of Van de Venne’s representation of the Valkenburg horse fair are part of the preparation of a chapter on ‘Time and Temporalities’ in the Dutch Republic.


  1. In the case of this drawing, the artist identified the location of the fair (Hoboken) on the back: ‘Dit es / […] / hoboken / […] / […]’. ↩︎
  2. For a description of the painting, see the Rijksmuseum catalogue entry by Yvette Bruynen (2007): https://id.rijksmuseum.nl/200108368, including bibliography. Unfortunately, the format and word limit of these gems does not allow for an in-depth analysis. ↩︎
  3. It would have taken the company approximately a thirty minute carriage ride from The Hague to get to the fair. ↩︎
  4. To evoke an interesting example, Joris Oddens recently presented the depiction a particularly significant meeting of the States General, at which occasion the sovereignty of the Dutch Republic was first acknowledged: https://doi.org/10.51750/emlc19457. ↩︎
  5. This observation deserves further substantiation. Within our project Marie Verbiest and Alexander Goderniaux are conducting extensive research of such sources. The conference of Marion Pouspin was equally inspiring. ↩︎
  6. Lairesse, GS, vol. I, 86. ↩︎
  7. Point 1, 2, and 3: Hoogstraten, 96: ‘Datmen voornamentlijk op drie dingen te letten heeft, waer van het eerste is, de personaedjen, die ontrent de geschiedenis bezich zijn, te kennen; […] Ten tweeden moetmen de daed der Historie wel deurgronden, en aen wie het doen of lijden meest belangt:[…] Ten derden moetmen op tijd, plaets, en omstandicheyt acht geven;[…].’ Lairesse emphasizes that the inclusion of people from all walks of life appropriate to the history will make the painting more convincing Lairesse, GS, I, 53). ↩︎
  8. Junius 1641, 303; Lairesse, GS, I, 142. ↩︎
  9. Hoogstraten, 93: ‘Eerstelijk zoo moetmen zich vast aen de waerheyt, of waerschijnelijkheyt houden, en niets anders uitbeelden, als dat is, of ten minsten zijn kan.’ ↩︎
  10. In 1618, De Hertoghe served as Quartermaster-General of the States army; he had bought a manor near Valkenburg in 1615 (see catalogue entry cited in note 2). ↩︎
  11. Perhaps the other depicted dignitaries also held public functions in the government. A trip to the fair would have constituted a welcome moment of relaxation. We should be reminded this is the time of the Twelve Year Truce in the war with Spain. ↩︎

Participation in ‘Jenseits der Stärke’ Conference by Marije Osnabrugge (Hamburg, 4-6 June 2026)

Post by: Marije Osnabrugge

Between 4 and 6 June 2026 the conference “Jenseits der Stärke: Imaginarien schwacher Kräfte in Kunst, Literatur und Wissenschaft“  will be held at the Warburg-Haus in Hamburg, Germany. The conference is organized by Caroline Adler, Franca Buss, and Gerd Micheluzzi in the context of the DFG-Kolleg-Forschungsgruppe »Imaginarien der Kraft«.

Conference description (from website)

Concepts of weakness today are often associated with a pathological or degenerative condition: a state of exhaustion, powerlessness, vulnerability, or the drying up of creative energies. Conversely, references to weakness have always offered opportunities to reflect on subtle forces beyond dominance or control, about the small, the potential, the (re)emerging. Weakness should therefore not only be understood as the opposite of strength. It also constitutes its own forms of agency. The conference takes this observation as a starting point to examine the connections and productive ambivalences of weak forces and their aesthetic articulations.

On Friday 4 June, I will present my paper ‘Den bogh’ en mach altijt niet zijn ghespannen’ : Van Mander and Hoogstraten on Weakness and Rest in the Artistic Profession‘, in which I will discuss my ongoing research on the restful practices of early modern Netherlandish painters and show how they dealt with temporary moments of weakness and lack of professional stamina in the face of the intense competition and accelerated (artistic) innovation that characterizes the ‘Dutch Golden Age’. Amongst others, I will propose that the well-known drawing of the Bentvueghels by Pieter van Laer (fig.) does not only represent one of the group’s infamous parties, but also a playful activity to restore the creative mind.

Pieter van Laer, The Bentvueghels in a Roman Tavern, c. 1625, washed drawing, Berlin, Staatliche Museen, credit: Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Kupferstichkabinett / Jörg P. Anders.

For more information and the conference programme, see the website of the DFG Research Group.

Colloque international “La ville au présent. Temporalités et rythmes urbains en Europe occidentale (XIVe-XVIIe siècles)”

EN

Du 1er au 3 octobre se tiendra à l’Université de Lille (France) un colloque international dédié aux temporalités urbaines.

DESCRIPTIF

« Les temporalités sont un code de lecture pour comprendre l’espace et rendre compte d’un monde complexe et contextualisé ». Cette citation que l’on doit à la géographe Françoise Lucchini (2015) ouvre une lecture originale de l’espace urbain, considéré au rythme de ses pulsations propres. La ville, comme espace construit, aménagé, vécu et pensé, a fait l’objet de nombreuses études, qui ont ponctuellement introduit une dimension temporelle à leurs réflexions, permettant de mieux saisir la dynamique de ses évolutions et des pratiques urbaines. Toutefois, il faut reconnaître que le « sens du temps », saisi au fil des rythmicités quotidiennes comme de l’organisation planifiée des lieux, a davantage retenu l’attention des géographes, urbanistes, sociologues ou des historiens des xixe et xxe siècles. L’accélération du temps induite par l’industrialisation, les grandes métamorphoses urbanistiques qui l’accompagnèrent et le développement des nouvelles technologies permet sans doute plus aisément de s’emparer de cette matière fuyante qu’est le temps et de forger, selon l’expression conçue par François Hartog (2003), un « régime d’historicité » présentiste, censément propre à la période contemporaine.  

Pourtant, les remarques de Peter Burke (2004), commentateur des observations pionnières de Jacques Le Goff sur le « temps du marchand », invitent depuis plusieurs décennies à explorer la matière vivante des villes du Moyen Âge et de la première modernité, pour mieux comprendre le sens de la multiplicité des temporalités qui se concentrent en un même lieu et forcent à interroger le rapport entre « le champ de l’expérience » et « les horizons d’attente » des communautés médiévales (Koselleck, 1979).

C’est tout du moins l’idée qu’aimerait défendre cette rencontre, inscrite dans le projet FNS-Sinergia « Capturing the Present in Northwestern Europe (1348-1648) ». Il s’agira de saisir non seulement la mesure du temps présent, mais aussi le ressenti de son écoulement, qui troublait tant l’esprit de saint Augustin et de tous ceux qui s’efforcèrent d’en donner une définition. La question du temps subjectivement vécu peut s’avérer d’une grande banalité. Mais la replacer dans un contexte particulier, déterminé par autant de paramètres que sont les lieux, les statuts sociaux, les âges, les activités, les ambitions individuelles ou collectives ou encore les impératifs politiques, économiques, etc. lui donne toute sa richesse et comble les vœux de Marc Bloch, pour qui l’histoire se doit d’approcher « le moment humain où ces courants se resserrent dans le nœud puissant des consciences » (Bloch,1949). Dans la comparaison offerte par une vaste Europe urbaine occidentale, qui viendra en appui aux études plus spécifiquement dédiées à sa partie septentrionale, afin d’en saisir les spécificités, le but de cette rencontre est d’observer les citadins pris dans le jeu des multiples temporalités qui les traversent et nourrissent leur sentiment d’appartenance ou d’exclusion à différents groupes sociaux.

Comment les habitants de villes (mais aussi celles et ceux qui les traversent) habitent-ils le temps présent ? Comment partagent-ils cette expérience individuelle au sein des communautés auxquelles ils se réfèrent ou sont assignés ? Peut-on parler de time communities (communautés temporelles), façonnées par les contours du groupe social, de l’adhésion politique ou du partage d’une même foi ? Sur quel socle culturel se fondent cette appréhension et cette représentation du temps présent, considéré autant pour lui-même que pour le passé qu’il synthétise et l’avenir qu’il annonce ? Autant de questions non limitatives qui nourriront la réflexion. Rythmes quotidiens, dynamiques de l’événement, temps de l’intime, maîtrise du risque et impacts de l’accident, suspension de l’action, sont autant de perspectives qui permettront aux historiens et historiennes des sources de la pratique, de la littérature et des images de s’interroger sur la ville vécue et pensée dans le(s) présent(s) de celles et ceux qui l’animent.

LANGUES

Français/anglais

ORGANISATEURS

Elodie Lecuppre Desjardin (elodie.lecuppre@univ-lille.fr) ; Sebastian Hackbarth (sebastian.hackbarth@univ-lille.fr) ; Anne-Frédérique Provou (annefrederique.provou@univ-lille.fr)

INFORMATIONS PRATIQUES

IRHiS-UMR 8529 (Univ. Lille, CNRS)

Salle de séminaire (A1.152)
Université de Lille
Site du Pont-de-Bois
59653 Villeneuve d’Ascq 

PROGRAMME

International conference “Present in the City. Urban temporalities and rhythms in Northwestern Europe (14th-17th centuries)”

FR

From 1 to 3 October, the University of Lille (France) will host an international symposium dedicated to urban temporalities

DESCRIPTION

“Temporalities are a common code for deciphering space and giving an account of a complex, contextualized world”. This quotation from geographer Françoise Lucchini (2015) opens up an original reading of urban space, considered in the rhythm of its own pulsations. The city, as a space that is built, developed, inhabited and conceived, has been the subject of numerous studies, which have occasionally introduced a temporal dimension to their reflections, enabling us to better grasp the dynamics of its evolutions and urban practices. However, it has to be said that the “sense of time”, captured in the rhythms of daily life and the planned organization of places, has attracted more attention from geographers, urban planners, sociologists and historians of the 19th and 20th centuries. The acceleration of time induced by industrialization, the great urban metamorphoses that accompanied it and the development of new technologies undoubtedly makes it easier to take hold of this elusive material that is time and to forge a presentist “regime of historicity”, supposedly specific to the contemporary period, according to the expression conceived by François Hartog (2003). 

And yet, for several decades now, Peter Burke’s (2004) commentary on Jacques Le Goff’s pioneering observations on “merchant time” has been inviting us to explore the living matter of medieval and early modern cities, to better understand the meaning of the multiplicity of temporalities concentrated in a single place, and to question the relationship between the “field of experience” and the “horizons of expectation” of medieval communities (Koselleck 1979). There is thus another cultural history of time to be written, in which forms of presentism other than the one that prevails today may have asserted themselves. 

At least, that’s the idea behind this meeting, part of the SNSF-Sinergia project “Capturing the Present in Northwestern Europe (1348-1648)”. The aim is to capture not only the measurement of present time, but also the feeling of its passing, which so troubled the mind of Saint Augustine and all those who strove to define it. The question of subjectively experienced time may seem trivial. But placing it in a particular context, determined by as many parameters as places, social status, ages, activities, individual or collective ambitions, political or economic imperatives, etc., gives it all its richness and fulfils the wishes of Marc Bloch, for whom history must approach “the human moment when these currents tighten in the powerful node of consciences” (Bloch, 1949). In the comparison offered by a vast Western urban Europe, which will support studies more specifically dedicated to its northern part, in order to grasp its specificities, the aim of this meeting is to observe city dwellers caught up in the game of multiple temporalities that cross them and feed their sense of belonging or exclusion to different social groups. 

How do city dwellers (and those who pass through these places) live in the present? How do they share this individual experience within the communities to which they refer or are assigned? Can we speak of time communities , shaped by the contours of a social group, political membership or shared faith? What degree of awareness and what cultural foundation underlies this apprehension and representation of the present, considered as much for its own sake as for the past it synthesizes and the future it heralds? These are just some of the questions that will be addressed. Daily rhythms, the dynamics of events, intimate time, risk control and the impact of accidents, the suspension of action – these are just some of the perspectives that will enable historians of practical sources, literature and images to examine the city as lived and thought in the present(s) of those who live in it. 

LANGUAGES

English/French

ORGANIZERS

Élodie Lecuppre Desjardin (elodie.lecuppre@univ-lille.fr ); Sebastian Hackbarth (sebastian.hackbarth@univ-lille.fr) ; Anne-Frédérique Provou (annefrederique.provou@univ-lille.fr)

PRACTICAL INFORMATIONS

IRHiS-UMR 8529 (Univ. Lille, CNRS)
Salle de séminaire (A1.152)

Université de Lille
Site du Pont-de-Bois
59653 Villeneuve d’Ascq 

PROGRAMME

Gem: Measuring and Sensing the Present – Our Project Logo

The dial’s use: determining, but also sensing the moment

The two sealed holes reveal that the panel originally featured a mechanism to indicate the time. The exact nature and functioning of this mechanism are unclear and must have been quite intricate. It would certainly have included hands to indicate the hour (the Roman numerals). Based on sixteenth- and seventeenth-century clocks and watches (fig. 5), we would furthermore expect some sort of frame (or several frames) that could be moved to highlight certain sections of the panel, for example to indicate the current month and zodiac sign, planet or day of the calendar.5 Matthew Champion has suggested the mechanism of this dial might have also included the phases of the moon, which was indeed a common feature of such devices.

TO COME

  1. This extraordinary manuscript is currently on display for the first time ever in an exhibition in Musée Condé at the Chateau de Chantilly ↩︎
  2. The Planetenkinder were often represented in the visual arts across Europe, for example in the so-called Salone dei mesi in Palazzo Schifanoia in Ferrara and on numerous paintings and prints. ↩︎
  3. The relation of the hour and planet shifted according to the weekday (the first daylight hour of each day was connected to the planet of the day). The order of the scenes on the dial follows the order of the weekdays associated to each planet. ↩︎
  4. I did not yet consult technical reports on the object to verify. ↩︎
  5. The Roman numerals on such watches and clocks are remarkably larger than on the object under discussion, perhaps indicating a decreased importance of astrological temporal markers. ↩︎
  6. Max Engammare, to name one example, insists on the role of clocks in the religious practices of Calvin and his followers in sixteenth-century Geneva (M. Engammare, L’ordre du temps: l’invention de la punctualité au XVIe siècle, 2004). ↩︎

Publication by Marije Osnabrugge: co-editorship special issue EMLC ‘Time and Temporality in the Early Modern Low Countries’ (2023)

Gerrit Verhoeven, Brecht Deseure and Marije Osnabrugge (eds.), ‘Time and Temporality in the Early Modern Low Countries’, special issue, Early Modern Low Countries 7.2 (2023).

DESCRIPTION

During the preparatory phase of the Sinergia project, Marije Osnabrugge had the opportunity to edit, together with Gerrit Verhoeven and Brecht Deseure, a special issue of Early Modern Low Countries (7.2., published 21 December 2023) on the theme of the perception of time in the early modern Low Countries.

Besides editing the various contributions by scholars from a range of disciplines (incl. political history, cartography, cultural history, literary history, art history)) and with different original approaches to this topic, the editors of the special issue co-wrote the introduction. The volume also includes a collective publication by Élodie Lecuppre-Desjardin, Jan Blanc, Thalia Brero and Marije Osnabrugge.

Table of contents

Introduction, Gerrit Verhoeven, Brecht Deseure and Marije Osnabrugge

Reasoning with Turbulence: A Quantative Analysis of Extraordinary Times in the Digitised Resolutions of the Dutch States-General (1705-1796) – Femke Gordijn

A Delta of Time: Claes Jansz Visscher’s Updated News Maps of Spanish-Dutch Battles in the Scheldt River Area, 1627-1640 – Anne-Rieke van Schaik

Revisiting Presentism: The Experience of the Present in Late Medieval and Early Modern North-Western Europe – Jan Blanc, Thalia Brero, Élodie Lecuppre-Desjardin, Marije Osnabrugge

Shared Futures in Times of Rupture: The Marriage Story of Daniel van der Meulen and Hester de la Faille 1584-1585 – Sanne Hermans

The Remains of the Night: Nocturnalization, Street-Lighting, and Urban Life in Eighteenth-Century Antwerp – Gerrit Verhoeven

[top image: David Bailly, Vanitas Still Life, in the album amicorum of Cornelis de Montigny de Glarges, 16 July 1624, pen on paper, The Hague, Koninklijke Bibliotheek.]

Conference participation: RSA Conference 2023

San Juan, March 9-11

DESCRIPTION OF THE SESSION

Chronotopes: Temporal Markers Shaping Space I

Chronotopes: Temporal Markers Shaping Space II

Colloque d’ouverture : 15–17 mai 2025

EN

Du 15 au 17 mai 2025 se tiendra à l’Université de Lausanne le colloque d’ouverture du projet FNS Singergia “Capturing the Present in Northwestern Europe (1348 1648), A Cultural History of Present before the Age of Presentism”

DESCRIPTIF

Ce colloque d’ouverture inaugure un projet interdisciplinaire et international, financé par le Fonds national suisse (FNS, programme Sinergia), mené aux universités de Lausanne, Lille et Neuchâtel. Il explore la manière dont le présent a été pensé, représenté et vécu dans l’Europe du Nord-Ouest, entre la peste noire et la guerre de Trente Ans, à travers trois axes de recherche consacrés aux formes du moment, aux événements et aux impératifs du présent dans les dynamiques de pouvoir.

INFORMATIONS PRATIQUES

Organisateurs

Jan Blanc (Université de Lausanne), Thalia Brero (Université de Neuchâtel), Estelle Doudet (Université de Lausanne), Élodie Lecuppre-Desjardin (Université de Lille), Marije Osnabrugge (Université de Lausanne)

Langues

Français et Anglais

Inscription

Aucune inscription requise

PROGRAMME

Consulter le programme

SOUVENIRS DU COLLOQUE D’OUVERTURE

Quelques images capturées “sur le vif” par Olivier Silberstein, coordinateur du projet.

Kick-off Conference: 15–17 May 2025

FR

From May 15 to 17, 2025, the opening symposium of the SNSF Singergia project “Capturing the Present in Northwestern Europe (1348 1648), A Cultural History of Present before the Age of Presentism” will be held at the University of Lausanne

DESCRIPTIF

This kick-off conference launches an interdisciplinary and international research project, funded by the Swiss National Science Foundation (Sinergia programme), based at the universities of Lausanne, Lille and Neuchâtel. It investigates how the present was conceived, represented and experienced in Northwestern Europe between the Black Death and the Thirty Years’ War, through three work packages focusing on the forms of the moment, the shaping of events, and the imperatives of the present in power dynamics.

INFORMATIONS PRATIQUES

Organizers

Jan Blanc (Université de Lausanne), Thalia Brero (Université de Neuchâtel), Estelle Doudet (Université de Lausanne), Élodie Lecuppre-Desjardin (Université de Lille), Marije Osnabrugge (Université de Lausanne)

Languages

French and English

Registration

No registration required

PROGRAM

Consult the program

MEMORIES OF THE KICK OFF CONFERENCE

A few moments “from life” captured by Olivier Silberstein, our project coordinator.